1 changed files with 153 additions and 0 deletions
@ -0,0 +1,153 @@ |
|||
<br>If you want to know how to calculate COGS for a service business, start with labor. For many firms that sell hours or expertise, the cost of the people who deliver the work is often the largest part of cost of goods sold. A cost belongs there only when it exists because a client bought the work.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Why labor comes first in a service business |
|||
|
|||
<br>A product company has a shelf. It buys inventory, sells it, and moves that inventory cost into the income statement at the moment of sale. A service business has no shelf. Its product is someone's time, so the cost of that time is the first thing to look at.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>In practice, this is where many founders get stuck. They look at the bank account, see payroll going out every two weeks, and file the whole thing under general expenses. That is not wrong, but it hides the number you need to judge pricing. If a project brings in a fixed fee and the team that delivers it costs more than that fee, the margin is gone before rent is even paid.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Here is a simple cash flow example. Say a small firm collects a monthly retainer from each client and staffs each account with one analyst. Payroll for those analysts leaves the bank every month, whether or not the clients pay on time. The cost of the analysts is not a general overhead question. It is the cost of the work the client bought.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Labor first does not mean labor only. Rent, software, insurance and the owner's own pay still matter, and you need them for the full picture. They just come second. If you start with overhead and spread it across clients, you can end up with a clean-looking report that says nothing about which engagements make money.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Before you build any spreadsheet, ask one question: if this person stopped working on client projects tomorrow, would the cost of delivering those projects drop? If yes, the cost probably belongs in COGS. If no, it probably belongs in operating expenses. It is a rough test, but it catches most mistakes early.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>The test has limits. A senior partner who splits time between selling and delivery needs a split, and that split should be written down and applied the same way every month. A rule you change whenever the numbers look bad is not really a rule, and a lender or buyer will notice the change.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Which people belong in cost of goods sold |
|||
|
|||
<br>The people who belong in COGS are the ones whose time is billed, or [venturegrowthpartners.com/locations/florida-miami-fractional-cfo-services/](https://gitlab-rock.freedomstate.idv.tw/michaelamarkha) could be billed, to a client. That usually means analysts, consultants, and project managers who run the delivery itself. Administrative staff, sales reps, and an owner who mostly sells do not belong there, even if they work hard and care about the clients.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Sorting roles is easier with a table. The point is not the table itself but the habit of deciding each role before the month closes, so the numbers do not shift every time someone asks a question.<br> |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
|
|||
RoleUsually in COGS?WhyWatch for |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
Client analystYesTime billed to a clientCount only hours spent on client work |
|||
Project manager who runs deliveryOften yesCoordinates the work the client buysSplit the time if the same person also sells |
|||
Account manager or sales repNoWins the work, does not perform itCommissions are usually operating expenses |
|||
Bookkeeper or office managerNoSupports the whole businessStays in overhead even if busy |
|||
Owner who does client deliveryPartlyTime on client work countsRecord it, or the margin will look too high |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
|
|||
<br>Commissions deserve a note. Many founders put sales commissions in COGS because they are tied to revenue. In most setups they are a selling cost and belong in operating expenses. Your accountant can confirm how your chart of accounts should treat them, so the gross margin you show a lender or buyer stays consistent from one report to the next.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Part-time staff and interns follow the same rule. Their pay goes into COGS for the hours they spend on client work, and the rest goes elsewhere. The trap is moving a whole salary into COGS because someone "mostly does delivery." That inflates your cost and makes a healthy account look weaker than it is.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Write the rule down. A short list of which job titles count, and which tasks inside a job count, is enough. Keep it in the same folder as your chart of accounts. When someone asks why the margin moved, you can point to the rule instead of a feeling.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Here is a hypothetical case to test the rule. A three-person team has two analysts working full time on client accounts, and an office manager who splits time between invoicing and scheduling. The two analysts go into COGS. The office manager stays in overhead. The owner, who sells and also reviews client work, is split by a rule written before the month starts.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>The hardest part is not the first decision. It is keeping it the same for twelve months. A rule that holds through a slow quarter and a busy one gives you a trend you can trust. A rule that shifts with each report gives you noise.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Turning payroll into a labor cost per hour |
|||
|
|||
<br>Salary is not the labor cost. It is only the starting point. Payroll taxes, workers' compensation insurance, health benefits, retirement contributions and paid time off all add to what the business spends to keep someone on the team. In the United States, employers pay their share of Social Security and Medicare taxes on top of wages, so the real bill is higher than the number on the offer letter.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Start with the annual cost of each person. Take the salary, add the employer's share of payroll taxes, add benefits and insurance, and add any bonus you expect to pay. Most payroll systems report much of this. If yours does not, ask your provider or your accountant to show you where each figure comes from, and keep that source on file.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Then convert the annual figure into an hourly cost. Divide the annual cost by the paid hours that are actually available for work, not by the full calendar year. Holidays, sick days and vacation reduce the hours that can be billed. This is the step most spreadsheets skip, and it is why many estimates look cheaper than the real cost of the team.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>A hypothetical example makes this concrete. Suppose an analyst earns $60,000 a year, and the employer's taxes, benefits and insurance add $15,000. The annual cost is $75,000. If the analyst has 1,800 paid hours available in the year, the cost works out to about $41.67 an hour. The numbers are invented, so use your own payroll figures, but the method is the same.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Cash flow matters here too. That $75,000 leaves the bank in regular payroll runs, whether the client has paid or not. A monthly view of payroll cost per person tells you when a slow-paying client is hurting you. You do not need a complex model for this. A list of who is paid what, and when, goes a long way.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Refresh the rate once or twice a year. Raises, new benefit plans and changes in insurance premiums all move the cost. An old rate keeps producing margin reports that look better than they really are, and that kind of error tends to surface during a lender's review, when you have the least time to fix it.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Dividing labor by the hours that reach a client |
|||
|
|||
<br>The hourly cost is only half the calculation. The other half is how many of those paid hours actually reach a client. A person paid for a full week might spend most of it on billable work, but some of it goes to internal meetings, training, sales support and waiting for the next project. That unbilled time does not disappear. Somebody has to pay for it.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>This is where utilization comes in. Utilization is the share of paid hours spent on billable client work. In a hypothetical case, if a team is paid for 100 hours and bills 70 of them, utilization is 70 percent. Use that figure to decide how much idle time to carry in COGS and how much to treat as overhead.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>There are two common ways to handle idle time. Some firms load the unbilled hours into the hourly rate, so every billable hour carries a share of the bench. Others keep idle time on its own overhead line, so COGS reflects only delivery and the cost of waiting work shows up where the owner can see it. Either approach can work. The problem starts when a firm switches between them because one method makes the numbers look worse.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Which approach fits depends on the business. A firm with steady, predictable client work can load idle time into the rate without distorting much. A firm with lumpy projects, where a team may sit idle for weeks between contracts, usually gains clarity by showing idle cost on its own line. That way a slow quarter does not look like a pricing problem when the real issue is sales timing.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Watch the hours that are not billable but still count as delivery. Reviewing a client's file before a call, answering a client's questions after hours, and redoing work after a mistake on your side all fall into this group. Some firms treat rework as a cost of delivery, and others write it off. Pick one, record it the same way every month, and note the choice so the next person follows it.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Recording hours matters more than the formula itself. If nobody tracks where the time goes, the utilization number is a guess dressed up as a metric. A rough record that is kept consistently is more useful than a detailed one that is filled in only at the end of a quarter.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Contractors and outside delivery costs |
|||
|
|||
<br>Not everyone who delivers client work is on payroll. Freelancers, subcontracted specialists and outside firms that handle part of an engagement are common in service businesses. Their invoices are a direct cost of delivery when the work they do is part of what the client bought. Record those costs in COGS as they are billed, matched to the engagement they support.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>The key word is direct. A contractor who prepares the monthly close for one client is a direct cost of that client's work. A contractor who redesigns your website is not a delivery cost. That belongs in marketing or overhead. Keep a short note on each contract that says which engagement, or which part of the business, it supports.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Contractors create a timing problem. Invoices often arrive weeks after the work is done, and sometimes after the client has already paid you. In a cash view, a project can look profitable at first and then turn negative when the bills come in. If your accountant recommends it, record an accrual, which means booking the cost in the month the work happened, even though the bill arrives later.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Some outside costs pass through to the client. If a client agreed to pay for travel or a specialist's report, the cost and the reimbursement both belong to that engagement, and the client's invoice should show the same treatment. If you absorb the cost yourself, it becomes a delivery cost. Either way, the treatment should be consistent from one invoice to the next, so the margin does not swing for reasons nobody can explain.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Before you hire an outside firm for delivery, ask how its pricing is structured. A fixed monthly fee is easy to match to a client. An hourly invoice with no description of the work is harder to verify. A vague scope is the first red flag, here as with any hire. Ask what you will receive each month, and whether the invoice will tell you which engagement the work supported.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>If a contractor bills a set amount for the month and that work supports two clients equally, split the cost by a rule you can explain, such as hours logged or deliverables completed. Do not split it by which client you like more or which one is paying on time. A split that feels fair in the moment can look arbitrary to a lender reading the report later.<br> |
|||
|
|||
Where to record time so the numbers hold up |
|||
|
|||
<br>The labor calculation depends on time records. Without them, you are dividing an estimate by another estimate. Time can be recorded in a dedicated time tracking tool, in the project module of an accounting system, or in a simple shared spreadsheet. The method matters less than whether someone reviews it every week and whether each entry is tied to a client and a task.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Many small teams already use QuickBooks, which includes time tracking that can link hours to customers. Larger service firms often run NetSuite or Sage Intacct, which include project accounting and can report cost by engagement. Salesforce is widely used for pipeline and account work, and some teams connect it to time or billing tools. Planning platforms such as Adaptive Insights and Prophix are built for budgets and forecasts. They can model a labor cost per hour, but they do not replace the time records themselves. Check what your current system already does before you buy something new.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>A practical rule: time entries should be made daily, or at least weekly, and they should say what was done and for which client. A line that reads "client work, all day" is not useful when someone asks which engagement those hours supported. The entry does not need to be long. It needs to be specific enough to tie to an invoice.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Track non-billable time too. You do not need the same level of detail, but you need to know how much time went to internal work, sales and training. That is the number that tells you whether the bench is growing faster than the client work, which is often the first sign of a pricing or staffing problem.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Connect the time records to payroll each month. Total paid hours from payroll should roughly match the hours recorded plus approved absences. If they do not, something is missing, and it is usually a person who forgot to log time rather than anything more serious. Reconciling monthly catches the gap while it is still small. Reconciling once a year makes it much harder to explain.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Keep the records simple enough that people will actually use them. A tool that takes ten minutes a day will be abandoned within a month. Choose the lightest method that still gives you the client, the task and the date for each entry. A simple system that is used every day beats a sophisticated one that is ignored.<br> |
|||
|
|||
When the full calculation is worth the effort, and when it is not |
|||
|
|||
<br>A full COGS calculation by engagement is not free. It takes time from the owner or the bookkeeper, it needs clean payroll and time data, and it has to be maintained. So the real question is not whether the method is accurate in theory. The question is whether the answer will change a decision you actually make.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>It is worth doing when you price work by the hour or by the project and need to know whether each price covers delivery. It is also worth doing before you raise money, negotiate a loan, or prepare for a sale. A buyer or lender will test your gross margin, and they will ask how it was built. If you cannot explain the method, the number itself will not help you much.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>The full calculation is worth doing in these cases:<br> |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
You quote fixed fees and need to know whether each one covers delivery. |
|||
Two or more service lines share the same staff, and you cannot tell which one is profitable. |
|||
Your margins fall while revenue grows. |
|||
A lender, investor or buyer will ask for gross margin by service line. |
|||
You are deciding whether to hire another delivery person. |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
<br>It is usually not worth the full effort when the business is very small, when one person does nearly all the work, or when every client gets the same service at the same price. In that case, a simple monthly gross margin, with labor as the main cost line, may be enough to spot problems early. You can add detail later, when the business needs it.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>The full calculation is usually not worth it in these cases:<br> |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
You offer one service at one price, with the same team on every job. |
|||
Your books are behind by several months, so any margin figure you calculate would already be out of date. |
|||
Payroll and time data are not reliable yet, and fixing them is the first job. |
|||
Your main worry is cash, not profit per client. A 13-week cash flow forecast answers that question more directly. |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
<br>Think in stages. Early on, a rough labor cost per hour and a monthly check on margin are often enough. As the team grows and clients start to overlap, move to cost by engagement. The goal is to match the effort to the decision in front of you, not to copy a method you read about because it sounds thorough.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>A middle path works for many owners. Run the full method for your two or three largest clients once a quarter, and use the simpler rate for everyone else. You learn where the money goes without rebuilding the whole model every month. Over time, you can widen the detailed view as the business and its records mature.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>This is also where a [fractional CFO financial planning in Miami](https://venturegrowthpartners.com/locations/florida-miami-fractional-cfo-services/) CFO, a controller or an outsourced accountant can help you choose a path. Each role has a different scope. A controller usually keeps the books and the month-end close running. A [fractional CFO companies in Miami](https://venturegrowthpartners.com/locations/florida-miami-fractional-cfo-services/) CFO is more likely to help you decide what the margins mean and what to do about them. Ask which role fits your stage before you commit, and ask what that person will deliver each month.<br> |
|||
|
|||
What to ask or confirm with a professional before you rely on the number |
|||
|
|||
<br>Before you rely on any COGS figure, especially one you plan to show a lender or a buyer, take a short list of questions to an accountant or finance professional. Bring your payroll register, your chart of accounts, and two or three engagements you know well. Concrete examples will get you better answers than general questions.<br> |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
Which roles and tasks belong in cost of goods sold for my business, and is that rule written down? |
|||
How should sales commissions, bonuses and owner pay be classified, and does that match the statements I already report? |
|||
Should idle time be loaded into the labor rate, or shown on a separate overhead line? |
|||
How do payroll taxes, benefits and paid leave enter the hourly cost, and how often should I refresh the rate? |
|||
How are contractor invoices recorded, and do I need accruals for work that is done but not yet billed? |
|||
If I report under U.S. GAAP, how does revenue recognition under ASC 606 affect when certain costs are matched to sales? |
|||
Which system will hold the time records, and who reviews them each week? |
|||
|
|||
|
|||
<br>Whoever you hire, ask what you will receive each month. A cost by engagement, a margin report, and a written list of the rules used is a clear deliverable. A promise to "clean up the numbers" is not. If the description is vague, the margin they give you will be vague too, and you will be making pricing decisions on guesswork.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Confirm one more thing: that the person reviewing your method has access to your payroll and time records, and enough time to check the work against them. A quick look by someone who has never seen your payroll is not a real review. Ask how they will test the numbers, not just whether they will look at them.<br> |
|||
|
|||
<br>Get the method in writing before the next month closes. A COGS number that changes its rules every quarter cannot tell you whether a service line is growing or shrinking. A written rule, reviewed once or twice a year, keeps the number honest and gives you something to test when the results look wrong. That is what makes the figure useful when a lender, an investor or a buyer asks how you got it.<br> |
|||
Write
Preview
Loading…
Cancel
Save
Reference in new issue